Red Cross response to both the hospital donated four times the cost of poor data error questioned said
heteropoly County MCH in the construction site ( August 5 photo). Xinhua News Agency issued
7 31, China Red Cross Society (microblogging) information platform, announced the release of project funds donated Yushu, of which more complex multi-county and county government Maternal and Child Health hospital were 14.2 million yuan of total investment, but the area is 1050 square meters and are 5600 square meters, causing users to question. Qinghai Red Cross responded that the rule is not multi-county area of ??5600 square meters and Child Health Hospital, but the 1050 square meters, the red error message will announce the staff report error.
two MCH cost disparity
>> question
According to the Chinese Red Cross Federation of published information, and miscellaneous multi-county MCH MCH Zhidoi County were 14.2 million yuan of total investment, but the former building area of ??1050 square meters, which is building a total area of ??5600 square meters, two MCH difference between the cost of more than four times. Users have also found houses, schools and hospital construction costs are quite different.
an accounting firm by the micro-Bo said after the earthquake in Yushu donated items, houses, hospitals compared with the average difference between the estimated construction cost of the poor, and local house prices were quite different. “The average construction cost per household houses 166,800 yuan; estimated construction cost hospitals an average of 5324 yuan/square meter, up to 13,524 yuan/square meter, a minimum of 2536 yuan/square meter; school construction costs for the average budget for 3792 yuan/square meters, up to 5726 yuan/square meter, a minimum of 1407 yuan/square meter. “microblogging in the subsequent comments, a lot of users questioned the high cost of building hospitals in Yushu.
Red Cross staff error data
>> response
Qinghai Red Cross Executive Vice Sun Lin said, the users questioned, Qinghai Province, the Red Cross attention, an investigation team to the Yushu special project funds and to investigate various aspects of information dissemination. Initial investigations revealed that the Chinese Red Cross Society information release platform data published is wrong. In fact, two of the MCH are 1050 square meters construction area, so the cost is no different.
Ren Fumin, deputy director of the Office of Qinghai Province, the Red Cross, said: “The survey found that the incident is a Department of Qinghai Province, the Red Cross relief workers in the material submitted to the Chinese Red Cross Society when data entry errors caused. “He said that staff are not familiar with the situation in Yushu donated items, to another project” rule more than the county People’s Hospital building area of ??5,600 square meters, “error input to the” rule of multi-county MCH “column. Since then, no review of the materials to the competent leadership, but directly submitted to the Association. Also not always be checked with other documents, resulting in erroneous data were eventually released out.
Sun Lin apologized for this incident. Information submitted in the event exposed the Red Cross, publishing and other aspects of loopholes. Qinghai Red Cross will strengthen the system for future construction, construction management, to the public timely, open, transparent, accurate, comprehensive information for each release.
two MCH of the same size
>> surveys
Ren Fumin produced 2 documents. In the symbol “Green Development and Reform Commission (2011) No. 76″, “Qinghai Province Development and Reform Commission issued on post-disaster reconstruction Yushu 2010-2011 investment plan notice” of the file, miscellaneous construction of multi-county MCH area and the total amount of investment of 1050 square meters and 14.2 million yuan, including construction, “construction, ancillary facilities and equipment acquisition.” In a separate symbol “Green Investment Development and Reform Commission (2011) 237″, “Qinghai Province Development and Reform Commission issued the 2011-2012 post-earthquake reconstruction projects in Yushu pre-arranged plan to inform investment,” the document, rule MCH building multi-county area and the total amount of investment of 1050 square meters and 14.2 million yuan, including construction, “construction, ancillary facilities and equipment acquisition.”
Yushu reconstruction community to donate funds Management Center Rending Jiang, presented to reporters the Construction Bureau of Yushu, respectively, and Child Health Hospital of the two construction projects approved text, of which data and Qinghai Province Development and Reform Commission file the same.
reconstruction Fang Qinghai Haixi support multi-county government post-disaster reconstruction project headquarters staff Tianfa Wei confirmed to reporters, the county MCH administration building area of ??more than 1050 square meters, total investment of 14.2 million yuan.
Ghazall Yushu, executive vice president, said the Red Cross, hospitals questioned the high cost online is a kind of misunderstanding, because the information will always open platform, only the total investment, no specific construction of the content. In these two hospitals a total investment of 14.2 million yuan, in addition to construction also included the construction of ancillary facilities and some equipment acquisition costs. Schools, there are also device configuration problems, it will produce hospitals, schools and houses of the cost difference.
According to Xinhua News Agency Xinhua
[Media Review]:
Pearl River Evening News: Red will be back, led can not move?
Beijing News: “love” fade “insurance” exposed what
Changjiang Daily: a crisis of confidence rely on the lifting
welcome to comment I want to comment
> related reports:
media said the Red Cross situation will be difficult to meet the public information disclosure concerns
foreign media: Mei-US China Red Cross donations shrink incident
project has found love by the Red Cross charity to sell insurance
microblogging Recommended | today microblogging hot (edit: SN034)
